Pick Your Vibe Mystery Pack

You pick the vibe. We pick the exact designs.

Want a surprise without going completely random?

Choose your pack size, preferred format, and overall vibe. We’ll put together a mystery assortment of Frog Mustard stickers, magnets, or both based on your selections.

You control the general direction. We handle the exact designs and the chaos.

Choose your pack size

• 4 items
• 6 items
• 10 items
• 24 items

Choose your format

• All Stickers
• All Standard Magnets
• All Extra-Thick Magnets
• Sticker + Standard Magnet Mix
• Sticker + Extra-Thick Magnet Mix

Mixed packs are divided evenly:

• 4-pack: 2 stickers + 2 magnets
• 6-pack: 3 stickers + 3 magnets
• 10-pack: 5 stickers + 5 magnets
• 24-pack: 12 stickers + 12 magnets

Standard and extra-thick magnets are not combined in the same mixed pack. Choose the magnet type you prefer before adding your pack to the cart.

Pick your vibe

Choose the category that best fits your taste:

• Funny & Unhinged
• Driving-Specific Humor
• Pets & Animals
• Cats Only
• Cats, Raccoons & Possums
• LGBTQ+
• Politics & Conspiracy
  
• Religious
• Food & Drinks
• Dealer’s Choice

Choosing Dealer’s Choice gives us permission to select the full assortment for you. Browse our "Shop by Vibe" categories to see what is offered in each category.

Want to combine two vibes?

Use the optional request box to tell us your second choice.

For example:

• “Half Skeleton-style humor and half Cats Only”
• “Mix Pets & Animals with Funny & Unhinged”
• “Politics & Religion, but nothing election-specific”
• “Dealer’s Choice, but please avoid food”

When two vibes are requested, we’ll divide the pack as evenly as possible.

Requests are not guaranteed and depend on available designs, but we’ll do our best.

How it works

1. Choose your pack size.
2. Choose stickers, magnets, or a 50/50 mix.
3. Pick your main vibe.
4. Add any optional requests.
5. We choose the exact designs and build your mystery pack.

What you’ll receive

Each pack includes:

• A surprise assortment based on your selected vibe
• Your chosen quantity and format
• Different designs whenever inventory allows
• A discounted per-item value compared with selecting the same number of individual designs
• A healthy amount of Frog Mustard chaos

Exact designs will vary. Product photos show sample assortments and do not guarantee specific items.

Want to choose every exact design?

Use our Build Your Own Sticker & Magnet Bundle instead.

That option is best when you want complete control over every item.

This mystery pack is for people who know the kind of stuff they like but still want the fun of a surprise.

Please note

• Specific designs are not guaranteed.
• Requests may be considered but cannot be guaranteed.
• We’ll avoid duplicate designs within the same pack whenever possible.
• Selecting a vibe does not mean every item will feature the exact same subject.
• Some designs may fit more than one category.
• Larger packs may include related designs to create a more varied assortment.
• Politics & Religion packs may include irreverent, profane, opinionated, or satirical designs.
• Mixed-format packs are split exactly 50/50.
• Mystery packs are already specially priced and may not qualify for additional bundle promotions.

For best results, please review and follow the full care and application instructions included with your order and available on our FAQ page here.

Sizing

• Rectangular bumper stickers are approximately 8.5” x 2.5”
• Die-cut stickers and magnets are typically 3–4”
• Sizing may vary slightly, especially on hand-cut magnet materials
• Mockup images are not to scale and may appear larger for visibility

Materials

• Made with premium all-weather vinyl
• Waterproof, smudge-proof, fade-resistant, and car wash safe (stickers) when properly applied
• Designed for outdoor use on smooth, clean, glossy surfaces
• Apocalypse-resistant, within reason

Magnets

• Standard magnets are 20 mil thick
• 30 mil extra-thick magnets are available and recommended for colder climates
• Magnets only stick to magnetic metal surfaces. Many modern bumpers are plastic, so please test your vehicle before ordering
• Try your trunk, doors, or side panels if your bumper is not magnetic

Basic Care & Application

• Apply only to a clean, dry, smooth, glossy surface
• Clean the surface thoroughly before applying and dry completely
• Avoid textured, plastic, rubberized, dirty, dusty, waxy, or low surface energy surfaces
• For best results, apply in mild temperatures and press firmly across the full design. Do not apply under 45 degrees F
• Wait 24–48 hours before washing your car after applying a sticker to allow the adhesive to bond
• Remove magnets before car washes or extreme weather (snow/extreme winds)
• Clean under magnets periodically to prevent trapped dirt or debris from affecting your paint

Important Surface Disclaimer
Frog Mustard products work best on glossy, smooth, clean, dry surfaces. Many coolers, kayaks, vehicle cladding, and similar items are made with low surface energy plastics, which can make it difficult for adhesives to bond, even with premium vinyl.

We cannot offer refunds for poor application, failed adhesion on textured/plastic/dirty/incompatible surfaces, or magnet incompatibility with non-magnetic vehicle panels. If you’re unsure about your surface, please message us before applying or purchasing.

Join Frog Army rewards automatically with your order. Earn Mud Bucks to spend on free stuff.